10 of the Most Popular Criminal Minds Fanfiction Stories of 2024

Spread the love

If you’re looking for the most popular Criminal Minds fanfiction, look no further.

Criminal Minds is an American police procedural crime drama television series created and produced by Jeff Davis. 

It follows a group of criminal profilers who work for the FBI as members of its Behavioral Analysis Unit (BAU). 

They use behavioral analysis and profiling to investigate crimes and find the unsub, the team’s nickname for perpetrators. 

The show tells the story of the team as they work on various cases and tackle their personal struggles.

Criminal Minds became one of the network’s most-watched shows throughout its 15-year-long run.

Its success has spawned a media franchise, with several spinoffs, including a South Korean adaptation and a video game.

With 15 seasons, Criminal Minds had 324 episodes.

It is a popular franchise that many enjoy.

And because of this, there are tons of fanfictions out there that revolve around the crime-filled world of Criminal Minds. 

This article will explore some of the best and most popular Criminal Minds fanfiction stories according to hits received on Archive of Our Own. 

1. Moving Forward

The author set this fan-favorite after Kate’s Death. 

Tony, struggling with work and relationships, finds himself falling apart. 

When things seem like they couldn’t get any worse, JJ, Paula Cassidy’s cousin, shows up.

Moving forward, it’s a tear-jerking story of loss.

With plenty of exciting twists, many rave about this fanfic.

2. Hurt! Spencer Reid Stories

Are you looking for a series of quick reads?

Then Hurt! is for you.

Hurt is a series of one-shots and many chapters following the life of Spencer Reid.

 Just like in the show, the chapters are linked to some degree with reoccurring themes.

Filled with moments of angst, hurt, and comfort, this fanfic has hooked many Criminal Minds fans. 

It is also perfect if you need a reason to restart the series.

3. Tony’s Little Black Book

This is a series of one-shots featuring hypothetical romances between Tony DiNozzo and various women from NCIS, Avengers, Bones, and more.

If you’re wondering what a romance looks like between Tony and a woman from recent pop culture, you may very well be able to find it in this fanfic!

4. No Difference

Derek has been in a lot of bad situations. But this one easily takes the cake.

This alternate universe features the Winchester supernatural world colliding with unsuspecting profilers. 

The author does an excellent job developing the intricate world.

It showcases the best of both worlds.

The best part is that the author keeps them in character! 

Set in the early season 7 of both shows, Derek Morgan and Doctor Spencer Reid clash with Dean and Sam Winchester.

No difference has a spot-on characterization, loads of action and comedic relief too.

5. Saturn Rising

“Maybe now that your one tether to this old life is gone, you can move on and allow yourself to find someone. Everyone needs a family to call their own, Willow, just like every boat needs an anchor to not get swept away at sea.” 

After regaining her privileges as a special agent, Willow Graham puts up a facade of calm which soon begins to fall apart. 

And yes, I said HER.

This fanfic features a female Willow Graham!

Tasked with stepping out of her shell, she stumbles upon a distinguished gentleman.

And he insists on being her friend.

But wait, how do you make friends? 

6. Fandom Preferences

Featuring a vast collection of characters, Fandom Preferences is features several fandoms.

It includes characters from Supernatural, Transformers, The Avengers, Criminal Minds, and more.

With chapters revolving around male characters and their (often romantic) history with you as the reader , this is a really unique fanfiction format.

You as the reader play a big role as the romantic partner of various pop culture men like Matt Murdock, Tony Stark, Sherlock Holmes, and more!

There are sections about how you and say, Tony Stark meet.

Or your’s and Bruce Banner’s first kiss.

Or your’s and Wolverine’s hobbies.

In short, this is a really unique fanfiction to check out if this summary has piqued your interest.

7. Fandom One-Shots

Fandom One-Shots is a series of quick reads.

It features characters from The Vampires Diaries, Criminal Minds, and more.

Imagine kissing Killian Jones awake from the sleeping curse, but he keeps his eyes closed to scare you.

This is an interesting collection of exciting stories staged around characters you love. 

8. The Girl Next Door and the Boy Who Needed Her

This alternate universe’s events occur after Spencer’s kidnapping by Tobias.

Picture this, you move into a new place, and Special Agent Doctor Spencer Reid is your next-door neighbor.

Soon you form a beautiful bond.

This fanfic features Special Agent, Dr. Reid from earlier seasons and his struggle with his addictions.

Although a little dark, this steamy slow-burning romance has left many readers wanting more!

9. Every Me and Every You

A case involving BDSM leads to something more. 

Have you ever pictured yourself in a steamy moment with Special Agent Doctor Spencer Reid?

Then this fanfic is for you. 

With character description and spaces to create your own, the author takes you into the story.

In this adult-themed piece, you’ll get a front-row seat as the author unravels a hot romance!

10. Illusions Lost

“Our experience is composed rather of illusions lost than wisdom acquired.”

Gibbs leaves for Mexico, and Tony’s gut is telling him Gibb’s in trouble.

Abby is too distracted by her grief to back Tony up.

So Tony goes to Penelope Garcia for help.

After all, if Garcia thinks a friend is in trouble, she’ll always turn to her Derek, trusting him to do the right thing.

Illusion Lost tells the tale of a team doing the minimum required for their job and an overwrought Abby to deal with.

This thrilling crossover of Criminal Minds and NCIS is popular among both fandoms.

Some say this story provides a satisfying ending for the Gibbs/Tobbs relationship.

Criminal Minds Fanfiction: Conclusion

I hope this article has helped you find some great Criminal Minds fanfiction!

These 10 are just a small sample of all the amazing stories out there.

So be sure to take a look and find your own favorite among them.

And if you have questions about this topic, feel free to leave a message in the comments below!

Lastly, if you want to read more top fanfiction posts on this blog, then check out:

Legal Information

This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Recent Posts

Author Trivia

Which Harry Potter book is JK Rowling's favorite? Click the image above to see if your guess is right!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More Posts