20 of the Most Popular Lucifer Fanfiction Stories to Read in 2024

Spread the love

If you are looking for the best Lucifer fanfiction, you’re in the right place! 

Lucifer is an American television show with six seasons and nearly 100 episodes. 

This show revolves around Lucifer Morningstar, the DC Universe’s version of the Devil

He leaves Hell and comes to Los Angeles, where he opens a nightclub and works as a consultant for the LA police department. 

There is a large cast of characters, many of whom have become fan favorites. 

The fanfiction world loves Lucifer and its characters with all their powers and abilities. 

There are some incredible Lucifer fanfiction stories, and this article will look at some of the most popular by the number of hits on AO3, alongside epic merch like this!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Keep reading to find out more!

1. Believer

The first Lucifer fanfiction that we will look at features Chloe and Lucifer. 

This story has thousands of hits and raving comments from fans worldwide. 

This story is told from Chloe’s perspective, making it particularly interesting. 

She is in love with the Devil and is determined for him to love her back. 

Chloe has found herself in an unusual situation and is unsure how to escape it. 

This story has everything you want in a Lucifer fanfiction, from drama to romance, plenty of action, and an excellent balance between fluff and angst. 

This is a long story, but is well worth the time spent reading. 

2. Punishers

Next up is a Lucifer fanfiction that focuses on Chloe and Lucifer.

This story occurs in an alternate universe where Chloe is a highly skilled spy. 

She consistently rejects Lucifer, but he sees it as another challenge he must tackle. 

Chloe wears knives strapped to her legs, and she is much more vicious and lethal than she looks. 

Though Chloe is not initially interested in Lucifer, they have much more in common than they may realize. 

This story is quite long, requiring some commitment.  

However, it’s an exciting love story between Chloe and Lucifer. 

3. Devil’s Bargain

In the next Lucifer fanfiction that we will look at, there is no lack of drama. 

Trixie gets kidnapped, and Lucifer will not stand for it. 

This story has some intense scenes not for the faint of heart. 

We get to see Lucifer in a new light, and he shows himself to be an excellent friend and hero to many people. 

We all love Trixie. After all, who can resist her adorable self? So, why not bring home a piece of her masterpiece to commemorate one of the show’s most iconic characters?

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

4. Castaway

This Lucifer fanfiction shows a new take on the events following the season 3 finale. 

The author of this story has taken these events and given us a whole new narrative that we have not seen before.

This story opens with Chloe investigating a murder. 

Her world changes forever when she realizes that the victim of this murder may not be entirely human. 

We follow Chloe as she learns that the next victim on this murderer’s list is Lucifer himself. 

She starts to ask herself, “Who prays for Satan?”

This story is dark, certainly, but it also contains quite a lot of happy fluff. 

Deckerstar fans may want to sport this adorable shirt while reading to really bring your shipping to the next level!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

5. Crystals

Next up is another highly popular Lucifer fanfiction. 

In this story, Chloe discovers secrets about Lucifer and his mysterious past. 

She comes face to face with some of the nightmares that Lucifer has faced, and now she must deal with them herself. 

Eventually, Chloe decides to help Lucifer recover and turn over a new leaf in life. 

They work together to rid Lucifer of the demons that haunt him. 

There is plenty of romance alongside this story’s drama and emotional turmoil. 

Chloe proves to be an excellent partner who truly cares about Lucifer. 

6. And Then There Was Light

In this Lucifer fanfiction, the story opens with Lucifer found half-dead in the desert. 

It’s a strange place for him to turn up, and no one is sure how he got there or why he is nearly dead. 

One thing is for sure: Chloe is determined to find the answers to all these questions. 

The evidence that Chloe uncovers is damning, and there is no way to escape the problems and trials that come next. 

Chloe’s world changes forever.

Meanwhile, Lucifer deals with the repercussions of his experience in the desert, mysteries and all. 

If you want a feel-good story, this is not for you. 

While there are some happy moments, this story is mainly about emotional trauma and solving murders. 

It is an excellent choice for someone looking for something a bit dark and different from the others. 

7. Detonation

Next is a Lucifer fanfiction that will leave you guessing at every turn. 

It features a few different characters that we have not seen much of yet, but it still focuses mainly on Chloe and Lucifer. 

This story picks up immediately following Lucifer’s 16th episode of season 2

Chloe saves Lux, and Lucifer finally gets the courage to go to dinner with her. 

He decides that it is time to show her who he is. 

As you may expect, Chloe has a massive reaction to this revelation, and it changes the course of their relationship forever. 

There are so many twists and turns in this story! 

8. Caging the Devil

The next Lucifer fanfiction we will look at today is a mature story. 

It has some adult content, including language, mature romantic content, and more. 

This story takes place after the events of season 3. 

In this story, Pierce traps Lucifer and realizes he must keep Lucifer imprisoned forever to live out the rest of his life in peace. 

Chloe and Lucifer find themselves more vulnerable than ever, both physically and emotionally. 

While fighting to survive, they are also fighting for their relationship. 

This is not an easy task, and the author of this story paints a beautiful picture of their struggle. 

We all wish we could just cage Lucifer and bring him home, but that’s impossible. Luckily, we’ve got the next best thing within our reach — this awesome Lucifer-inspired sweater!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

9. Unwritten

The next Lucifer fanfiction that we will look at has thousands of hits. 

It is famous in the fandom, and for good reason. 

This story picks up after the events of Chloe’s betrayal and before Eve’s arrival. 

It also features a bit of time travel, which is fun to read. 

In this story, Lucifer is spiraling everything in his life seems to be going wrong. 

He is unsure how to handle all the harrowing events and is doing anything to clear his mind. 

When he wakes up one day to an unknown toddler in his house, his life changes forever.

10. Love on the Fringes of Everything (In Everything You Do, Everything You Are)

In a peculiar turn of events, Lucifer strolls towards the Detective’s desk only to find a much smaller and subdued figure in her place — Beatrice Decker. 

Intrigued by her uncharacteristic behavior, Lucifer can’t resist approaching her, questioning the evident distress he senses. 

Lost in her thoughts, Beatrice greets him with a hesitant smile. 

As he attempts to unravel the mystery behind her unusual state, a connection deeper than usual emerges between the Devil and this troubled child.

And this curiosity sets the stage for an unforeseen chapter in their peculiar relationship.

11. This Rage is the One Thing I Get from my Father

Amid a supernatural escape from Greendale’s magical chaos, Sabrina Spellman finds herself in L.A., seeking refuge. 

Little does she know, the City of Angels has its share of celestial drama waiting for her

A chance encounter at a bar unveils Lucifer Morningstar’s haunting past — once a seemingly simple favor turned into a profound sacrifice. 

As Sabrina gets entangled with the devilish father, angelic uncle, and a perplexed detective, she must navigate the intricate web of divine secrets, family ties, and the consequences of a bargain struck in the shadows. 

Will Sabrina’s escape from one magical realm lead her to an even more enigmatic and dangerous destiny in the supernatural realms of Los Angeles? 

Uncover the mysteries as Sabrina Spellman becomes an unexpected player in the celestial drama of angels and devils.

Although we can’t be Sabrina here and acquire legendary figures in our lives, the next best thing we can get is this epic vintage shirt of everyone’s favorite devil!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

12. Deckerstar Prompts

The next Lucifer fanfiction we will look at differs slightly from the others. 

Rather than being one long story with a cohesive plot that progresses through each chapter, this is a collection of short stories based on prompts that were given to the author. 

Each chapter differs from the next, featuring various characters, relationships, powers, and plot points. 

Most of the stories in this collection feature Chloe and Lucifer as the focus, but that is not the case for every story. 

Some of these stories are short and simple, while others are longer. 

Some stories have action and adventure, and others focus more on romance and everyday life. 

13. Too Well Tangled

Having faced demons and angels and even being married to the Devil, Chloe never expected time travel to be part of her supernatural journey

Stranded in the past, she witnesses Marcus trying to manipulate a younger version of herself into love while the love of their lives is on a destructive path. 

Determined to intervene, Chloe is ready to defy timelines and alter the course of events, determined to save the one she loves from self-destruction.

14. The Devil and his Urchin

After experiencing the dissolution of her marriage, Chloe Decker seeks solace in a random bar.

She crosses paths with a stranger who playfully adopts a Devil persona. 

The encounter results in Chloe becoming a mother.

Fast forward seven years, and Chloe prepares for an interview with a new witness. 

To her profound surprise, the last person she expects to encounter is none other than Trixie’s father.

The unexpected reunion brings a wave of emotions and unexpected twists to Chloe’s life.

15. Heaven Talks But Not To Me

After Dan is shot at a crime scene, Lucifer has limited options. 

His choices carry unintended consequences.

It forces him to navigate the complexities of his relationship with Chloe, a reluctant friendship with Dan, and the presence of his twin brother.

You may want to sip your favorite drink while reading this one since it can get pretty intense and dark, and what better way to do just that than with this epic Lucifer Morningstar mug?

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

16. A Refraction of Light

In the labyrinth of Los Angeles, a sinister resurgence of criminal activity emerges, intricately tied to the dark legacy of the notorious Sinnerman. 

A newly circulated street drug becomes the sinister thread linking a string of heinous murders, casting a pervasive shadow over the city. 

As the LAPD confronts this evil force, Lucifer Morningstar and Chloe Decker find themselves at the heart of the mystery, wrestling with the complexities of their partnership.

Meanwhile, in the depths of Hell, Cain embarks on an ambitious ascent, scaling the infernal hierarchy

Fueled by relentless determination, he navigates the tumultuous landscape of the underworld, leaving an indelible mark on the realms below.

17. She’s Got The Devil’s Eyes

As Lucifer faces the necessity of returning to Hell to prevent the fulfillment of a prophecy, he and Chloe must bid a heartbreaking farewell. 

Their shared memories and the profound connection they built overshadow their rational decision-making ability. 

Lucifer’s world, once centered on earthly pleasures, now revolves around Chloe — a woman whose heartbreak mirrors the emptiness left in his wake. 

Despite the inevitability of his departure, a surprising twist unfolds, leaving behind an unexpected miracle on Earth.

18. Safe

After a night at Lux, Lucifer retreats to his penthouse feeling conflicted about the detective, Chloe, who had saved his home earlier. 

He struggles with the fear of her discovering his true self, especially after a session with Dr. Linda. 

Unexpectedly, his brother, Gabriel, arrives, disapproving of Lucifer’s lifestyle and expressing concern over Uriel’s death. 

A heated argument ensues, resulting in Gabriel violently attacking Lucifer and eventually chaining him in an abandoned warehouse.

As Lucifer endures, he clings to the hope that Chloe will rescue him.

Speaking of Lux, you may want this adorable sweater inspired by the iconic nightclub itself!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

19. A Softer Beginning

Lucifer, grappling with the aftermath of a devastating injury, finds himself in a perplexing predicament: a complete erasure of memories encompassing his earthly existence, the tumultuous past in hell, and even the events surrounding the Fall. 

Now facing an existential void, it falls upon Chloe to go on the intricate journey of reconstructing the fractured fragments of Lucifer’s identity, bridging the gaps that have rendered him an enigma to himself. 

As they navigate through the labyrinth of forgotten moments and suppressed truths, Chloe becomes the linchpin in the intricate puzzle of Lucifer’s lost self, determined to unveil the secrets that bind his celestial past to his earthly present.

20. A Darker Beginning

In an unexpected twist to the well-known tale of Adam and Eve, a much darker narrative unfolds, shrouded in secrets beyond even God’s knowledge. 

The reunion of Eve and Lucifer takes a nightmarish turn for the latter as haunting memories resurface, threatening his very survival

The revelation of a hidden truth sends shockwaves through the celestial realm.

It leaves everyone to grapple with the unsettling reality that challenges their understanding of the divine narrative.

Lucifer Fanfiction: Conclusion

I hope this article has helped you find some great Lucifer fanfiction!

These are just a tiny sample of all the fantastic stories out there.

So be sure to take a look and find your favorite among them.

And if you have questions about this topic, feel free to leave a message in the comments below!

Lastly, if you want to read more top fanfiction posts on this blog, then check out:

Seeing you’ve made it this far, you obviously love Lucifer, and what better way to commemorate the iconic TV series than this epic vinyl figure?

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Lucifer Fanart Extras:

Lucifer Morningstar fanfiction fanart
Lucifer Morningstar Fanart

Legal Information

This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Recent Posts

Author Trivia

Which Harry Potter book is JK Rowling's favorite? Click the image above to see if your guess is right!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More Posts