10 Of the Best Arrow Fanfiction Stories to Read in 2024

Spread the love

If you are looking for the best Arrow fanfiction, you are in the right place. 

Arrow is a superhero TV series focusing on the DC Comics character Green Arrow, whose real name is Oliver Queen. 

Oliver Queen spent five years shipwrecked on a mysterious island, and at the beginning of season one, he is reunited with his family. 

At night, he works as a vigilante who hunts down the bad guys listed in his father’s notebook. 

This series has a great ensemble cast and features some of the best characters in the DC universe. 

Many fanfiction stories take place in the Arrow universe, and this article will explore some of the very best. 

Keep reading to find out more. 

1. Forever is Composed of Now’s 

The first Arrow fanfiction that we will read today has over 250,000 hits. 

It is a very popular story, and you will quickly realize why. 

This is also a very lengthy story, but the time commitment required to read it is well worth it. 

This story takes place in the not-so-distant future, and things are not going well. 

The Flash travels back in time to visit Oliver and Felicity who have yet to meet him in their timeline. 

The Flash also has a small toddler with him, a toddler who begins calling Felicity and Oliver mom and dad. 

This surprises them, and they must figure out how to get The Flash and their young child back to the correct timeline. 

This story has a great balance of fluff and drama, as well as some action and romance. 

It is a well-written story, and the author is clearly a great writer who knows these characters very well. 

2. Pink on Green 

Up next is an Arrow fanfiction that is actually a collection of shorter stories. 

This is a very popular trend within the genre of Arrow fanfiction, so be prepared to see quite a few of them below. 

This collection contains 101 chapters, each of which is a different story. 

Some of these stories have ties to one another, but for the most part, they stand alone. 

This collection focuses largely on Felicity and Oliver and their relationship.

Sometimes this is a romantic relationship, but other times it is a platonic working relationship. 

Whatever the case may be, this is a fun collection full of action, tension, and romantic fluff. 

3. I Scream but No Sound Comes Out 

In this Arrow fanfiction, nearly everything you thought knew about the show is completely changed. 

This story opens with Oliver returning from Lian Yu after five years, but he returns a completely different person than when he left. 

He is traumatized and mentally exhausted beyond what any human should be capable of handling. 

His friends and family must figure out how to help and accept this new Oliver and find him professional help as soon as possible. 

His body is physically injured, but those injuries will heal with time. 

The biggest injuries that must be dealt with quickly are the mental ones. 

This story deals heavily with Oliver sorting through the trauma and stress of the past five years of his life. 

It focuses a lot on mental health and mental disorders so that it may trigger some readers. 

Overall, it is a well-written story, and the author handles these sensitive topics with respect and care. 

4. Queen of Hearts 

The next Arrow fanfiction that we will look at is one of the most popular. 

It has over 160,000 hits, and that number is constantly growing. 

In this story, Felicity discovers that she is pregnant. 

The only problem, however, is that neither Felicity nor Oliver can remember how it happened. 

The two of them race against time to figure out what is happening and to decide their next steps. 

This story is fun and fluffy, and it is a great one to choose if you are looking for something lighthearted and sweet.

5. Caught in the Rapture 

In this Arrow fanfiction, we focus largely on Felicity Smoak. 

She is the daughter of a ruthless and notorious crime lord, and she is certain that her life cannot get any worse. 

When her father sells her off to be married as a peace offering, she quickly realizes that her life can actually get worse. 

She sees this as a sentence worse than death, but it just might be her only hope for freedom and starting over. 

She is determined to make the best of the situation and escape to begin a new life. 

Though this story uses a very popular fanfiction trope, it is done in a unique way and results in an interesting story that will have you on the edge of your seat.

6. Collection to be Named Later 

This Arrow fanfiction is another collection of short stories. 

A great table of contents indicates which stories can be found where, and this allows you to skip around and read the ones that interest you most. 

The author of this collection has taken suggestions and prompts from their readers, resulting in some very unique stories. 

They are all well-written, though some of them do tend to get a bit off the rails at times. 

A few chapters contain some adult content, but the author has appropriately marked these stories if you choose to skip over them. 

There are currently 115 stories in this collection, with more to come, so it is a collection that you won’t want to miss.

7. The Reluctant Queen 

Up next is an Arrow fanfiction that you won’t want to miss. 

In this story, we see how Oliver’s life is immediately changed when Felicity sets foot in his office for the first time. 

What starts as a nice encounter quickly changes into Felicity blackmailing Oliver into marrying her. 

As if that wasn’t shocking enough, this isn’t the only way in which Felicity changes Oliver’s life. 

The two of them are reluctant partners, but it turns out to be a partnership that is one to be reckoned with. 

They are powerful apart, but they are unstoppable together. 

This story has just under 80,000 words, so it is on the shorter end, but it is still a captivating story.

8. You’ve Gotten Into My Bloodstream 

Up next is the final Arrow fanfiction collection that we will look at today. 

Most of these stories take place in an alternate universe focusing on Oliver and Felicity. 

There are some really fun stories in this collection, and the author has used some of the best tropes throughout the collection. 

The author of this collection has labeled each chapter with a summary or quote from the story that will give you a good indication if you want to read that particular chapter or not. 

Because these stories are not all related, it is easy to jump around and choose the ones that interest you. 

There are stories featuring Oliver and Felicity in college, as werewolves, as children, and everything in between. 

Don’t miss out on this great collection of stories.

9. Times Like These 

This Arrow fanfiction uses the very popular fanfiction trope of time travel. 

When a mysterious man from Felicity’s past returns to Starling City, Felicity is faced with memories that she wishes could be lost to time. 

His reappearance causes secrets and mysteries to be uncovered, and these new revelations change the course of her life forever. 

Along with these forgotten memories is another new threat that is determined to ruin Felicity’s life in any way it can. 

This suspenseful story is one of the more action-packed and intense on our list. 

With nearly 130,000 hits, it is clearly a popular story. 

10. Your Love is a Waiting Game 

The final Arrow fanfiction that we will look at today takes place in an alternate universe. 

It is a rewrite of season two of the show. 

In this story, Oliver returns to Starling City after The Undertaking. 

Felicity and Oliver are back in their roles as associates, that is until one night of lowered inhibitions leads to a positive pregnancy test. 

Luckily, or perhaps unluckily, Oliver has no memory of this night, and Felicity is left to make all of the difficult and life-changing decisions on her own. 

It seems that things cannot get any worse, but this is just the beginning of Felicity’s bad luck. 

Her life is about to change forever, and there is nothing she can do to stop it. 

This story is fun and romantic and has some moments of suspense and tension. 

Best of all, this is just part one of a series by the same writer.

Arrow Fanfiction: Conclusion

I hope this article has helped you find some great Arrow fanfiction!

These 10 are just a small sample of all the amazing stories out there.

So you may want to look at the other fanfics with this tag and find your own favorite among them.

And if you have questions about this topic, feel free to leave a message in the comments below!

Lastly, if you want to read more top fanfiction posts on this blog, then check out:

Legal Information

This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Recent Posts

Author Trivia

Which Harry Potter book is JK Rowling's favorite? Click the image above to see if your guess is right!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More Posts