The 10 Most Popular Supergirl Fanfiction Stories to Read in 2024

Spread the love

If you are looking for recommendations on some of the best Supergirl fanfiction, then you have come to the right place. 

For those who may be unfamiliar, Supergirl is a television show based on the character of Supergirl from DC comics. 

Supergirl is the cousin of Superman and she is one of the last surviving Kryptonians.

There are six seasons of this show, and during its run on TV, it amassed quite a following. 

This show has everything that audiences are looking for in a superhero show, including action, adventure, amazing powers, and romance. 

The large following of this show spurred fans around the world to start writing fanfictions about Supergirl and her friends and enemies. 

There are countless Supergirl fanfictions out there, and some of them are really incredible to read and enjoy. 

Keep reading to find out more about some of the most popular Supergirl fanfiction stories by views.  

1. Maggie Sawyer’s Guide to Befriending Aliens, Fighting Crime, Saving the World, and Getting the Girl 

In the first Supergirl fanfiction, we see Maggie and her new partner, Kara. 

Maggie is very wary of her new partner due to her physical appearance, but she soon finds that Kara is much more than she bargained for. 

She is strong and powerful and a great match for Maggie. 

The twist to this story is that Kara has an older sister who Maggie just might be in love with. 

As you can expect, this story involves plenty of drama. 

Alongside all of the drama, there is also romance, humor, and a lot of feel-good moments. 

If you are looking for a Supergirl fanfiction that reads almost like a Hallmark movie, then this is the one for you. 

Between the friends-to-lovers trope and the heartwarming friendships, there is a lot of sweetness to be found in this story. 

2. This is What Broke Kara Danvers

In this Supergirl fanfiction, we get to see what finally breaks Kara Danvers. 

Or maybe I should say, we get to see who finally breaks Kara Danvers. 

Their names are Luna and Chris. 

We all know that Kara comes from a troubled background. 

She had a hard past that has always followed her, but somehow she remained positive and happy. 

That is until she was finally broken.

In this story, we see how she deals with more struggles, including people finding out that she is Supergirl. 

Without giving too much away, just know that this story is somewhat depressing, but it does have some nice moments. 

There are plenty of sweet moments between Kara and her friends to make up for the struggles and hardships that she faces. 

3. Words We’ll Say in Greeting

In this alternate universe story, we get a glimpse into a few other universes that all collide together. 

Not only do we get to see the universe of Supergirl, but we also get to see interactions with characters from Arrow, The Flash, and Legends of Tomorrow. 

The DC Universe comes together in one dramatic, shocking, and entertaining story. 

This is quite a long story, with over 54,000 words, but it is well worth the effort. 

In this story, Kara has tattoos on her body that indicate the first words that her soul mate will speak to her. 

What is unusual about this is that most people only have one tattoo, but Kara has two. 

This means that she has two soul mates out there. 

To find out who her soul mates are, and how the story unfolds, you will have to read the story. 

It is a dramatic and romantic story that will leave you on the edge of your seat. 

4. To be Yours

If you are looking for a story with time travel and many different universes, this is the one for you. 

This story diverges quite a lot from what we see on the show, but it is certainly a story worth reading. 

Kara jumps to a different timeline and meets a different Lena. 

In this timeline, Kara and Lena had never met. 

As you can expect, this creates quite a lot of tension and conflict that must be resolved. 

The author does an excellent job of taking the characters we love and putting them into new situations that we have never seen before. 

They remain quite true to who they are, while also becoming new, dynamic people at the same time. 

This story is complete, so it is a great one to dive into knowing exactly what to expect in terms of length. 

What you may not expect, however, are all of the twists and turns that the author throws your way. 

5. The Legend of the Green Arrow

Supergirl fanfiction fanart

This is another story that involves many different TV shows coming together in one epic story. 

Unique to this story is the mature themes and adult content that is included. 

The author does a great job of handling sensitive topics with respect and grace, but make sure to read the warnings before you decide to take a read. 

Though the main character of this story is Oliver Queen, we still get a large amount of Supergirl action. 

This story covers just about every character in the Arrowverse, so there are many great moments with so many unique groupings of characters. 

This story is incredibly lengthy, but it is also very popular, with good reason. 

The writing is excellent, and the storytelling is unique and fun to read. 

There is drama, action, plenty of tension, and lots of humor in this great story. 

It is not one to miss. 

6. Therapy

In this light-hearted Supergirl fanfiction, we get a look into the compulsory therapy that DEO Agents undergo. 

It takes place at the end of season 2, and each chapter focuses on a different character. 

This story is very unique in its premise, but it is also really well-written and fun to read. 

There are moments of humor as well as moments of sorrow and sadness, but they all come together perfectly. 

Though this story is a large divergence from what we usually see on the show, it is fun to see these characters in a different setting. 

The author does a great job of giving us insight into their minds and what they are thinking, while still staying true to the characters we know them to be. 

This is another long story that is still being updated, so get ready for a commitment that will take you some time to get through. 

It is a story that is well worth the effort, and it all pays off in a really nice way. 

7. How Did We End Up Like This?

The next Supergirl fanfiction that we will look at is another one that merges several different shows together. 

They all exist in the same universe and they work so well together, that it makes sense for authors to use them all in the same story. 

We get to see a lot of fun relationships and interactions come together, and they are unlike anything we have seen before. 

This story diverges from the show, but it is absolutely worth it. 

There are a lot of sweet moments that come from the author using a lot of common, but excellent, tropes in their writing. 

We see quite a few slow-burn romances, as well as many friends-to-lovers romances come together. 

Each of these is a lot of fun to read, and they are the main focus of this story. 

Of course, there is still plenty of action and adventure to be had. 

8. In Which the Arrowverse Ladies Actually Get to Talk to One Another

As the title suggests, this is yet another story that brings together characters from all over the Arrowverse. 

Maggie, Luna, and Kara are obviously involved, but we also get to see Felicity, Kendra, Caitlin, and so many more also make appearances. 

This is another fun story that takes place within a group chat. 

Just about every woman in the Arrowverse is in this chat, so it makes for a lot of humorous and dramatic moments. 

The author stays true to who the characters are, but they each have their own personalities and ways of speaking.

It is a lot of fun to read. 

If you are more interested in the men of the Arrowverse, don’t worry, they also make appearances from time to time. 

9. You Are What You Appear to be

This next Supergirl fanfiction is quite a turn from the previous one. 

There is nothing lighthearted or fun about this story, but it is still very engaging and entertaining to read. 

This mature story brings some intense themes together, such as abuse, violence, and death. 

Definitely read this one at your own risk. 

With that being said, however, it is still a great story to choose if you are looking for something a bit dark and heavy. 

We can’t read things that are happy and fluffy all the time, right?

The author of this story is a phenomenal writer who is able to write painful and heartbreaking beats that will tug at your heart. 

For fans of Supergirl and all of the lore that goes along with it, this is a story that will definitely have you reaching for the tissues more than once. 

10. The Best Influence

The final Supergirl fanfiction for us to look at today is another one that brings the whole Arrowverse together. 

Just about every character you could hope for makes an appearance in this story, and because it is such a long one, we get a good amount of content from each of them. 

This story is full of drama, mystery, twists, and turns, as well as a bit of humor and fluff. 

It takes place in a high school in which all of our beloved characters are students. 

Though it is quite different from the show, it has a way of pulling you in and keeping you interested. 

We get a lot of slow-burn romance, which is always fun to read. 

This story has a bit of mature content, but can still be read by discerning teen audiences.

If you are looking for a story that will keep you guessing, this is a great one to choose. 

Supergirl Fanfiction: Conclusion

I hope this article has helped you find some popular Supergirl fanfics to read!

And if you have questions about this topic, feel free to leave a message in the comments below!

Lastly, if you want to read more about fanfiction on this blog, check out:

Legal Information

This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

Recent Posts

Author Trivia

Which Harry Potter book is JK Rowling's favorite? Click the image above to see if your guess is right!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More Posts