10 Popular Jake and the Never Land Pirates Fanfiction in 2024

Limited Supply!
The Best Apple Cider Vinegar Gummies

Before diving into this article, you may want some delicious gummies to enjoy while reading. If so, we recommend these!

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Jake and Izzy fanart

If you are looking for the most popular Jake and the Never Land Pirates fanfiction, this is the post for you.

Jake and the Never Land Pirates is an American animated TV musical for preschool children on Disney Junior.

The story is based on Peter Pan and follows Jake, Izzy, Cubby, and a parrot on their pirate journeys.

So if you like animated children’s shows, then Jake and the Never Land Pirates might be just the thing for you.

Along with the TV show, a whole world of Jake and the Never Land Pirates fanfiction is also available.

But in this post, I will write about some of the most popular Jake and the Never Land Pirates fanfiction according to hits received on Fanfiction.net.

Keep reading to find out more about some of these popular stories.

1. Mysterious Feelings

In this fanfic, both Izzy and Jake are 14 years old now and have been pirates together for many years.

Lately, Izzy has noticed how her eyes keep drifting toward Jake and how her stomach churns whenever she sees him.

When Izzy falls asleep on the beach, she has a terrible nightmare.

Jake wakes her up and comforts her, but Izzy is having difficulty getting over her nightmare.

She isn’t sure if she should tell Jake about it and her feelings.

This fanfic feels a bit like a coming-of-age story and is very different from canon.

It is very short with only one chapter in the story.

2. The Tyranny of Captain Cronus

Teenage Izzy

There is a new pirate crew in Never Land, run by Captain Cronus.

They are strong, greedy, and evil and have no intention of being polite and sharing the treasures.

Not even Captain Hook is safe from this greedy lot, and soon everything in Never Land is in danger.

Jake and his pirate crew need to find a way to defeat Captain Cronus before it is too late.

The characters in this story are a little bit older than in the original TV show, but still, a lot follows canon.

It is 27 chapters long, but the chapters are a nice length and easy to read.

3. Jake’s Shadows of the Past

Bad boy Jake, all grown-up fanart

This story starts with a very dark event which then goes into a flashback to see how they ended up at that point.

Because of the dark subjects, it is very different from canon, so keep that in mind when reading this story.

Jake finds a journal that washed up on the beach and discovers that the journal belongs to his mother.

Of course, he is very excited to find something that belongs to his mother, especially since he has no memories of her.

But then he actually reads the journal, and everything he thought he knew about his life and family comes crashing down.

Now he has to deal with this new truth, which is hard for him.

4. Peter’s Wrath

a mean Peter Pan fanart

In this fanfic, Peter Pan finally returns to Never Land.

But he isn’t the same person as the last time the Pirate crew saw him.

He isn’t nice and fun anymore, but violent and abusive, and he is treating Jake and his friends badly.

Jake and Izzy are trying everything they can to get Peter Pan back to normal.

But they can’t be sure if it will work.

This fanfic doesn’t follow canon exactly, and it is way more violent than the kids’ TV show.

So keep this in mind when reading the fanfic.

5. Pirate Wedding

Red Jessica fanart

When Captain Hook finally proposes to Red Jessica, he is over the moon with her acceptance.

He spreads the news all over Never Land, but not everyone is happy with this news.

Peter Pan especially has a hard time dealing with Red Jessica getting married to his enemy.

Peter’s reaction impacts his crew, and they aren’t sure what to make of it.

The story is 10 chapters long, and it is primarily a very romantic story from Hook’s perspective.

6. Curse of the Never Land Werewolf

werewolf Jake

This story is much darker than canon and is classified as supernatural/horror story.

When the pirate crew is getting ready to return to Pirate Island, a strange creature shows up and bites Jake.

Because it is so dark out, nobody could really see who or what the creature was and Jake returns home with his pirate friends.

But then Jake starts to act strange, and his friends find out that he was actually bitten by a werewolf.

Now his friends must help him find a cure before Jake also turns into a werewolf.

This is a bit dark but a very nicely written story.

7. The Wrath’s Revenge

Teenage Izzy fanart

This fanfic is the sequel to Peter’s wrath, so make sure to read that one first before starting this one.

After the ordeal they had to go through with Peter, Jake and Izzy are convinced everything is done now.

But then Jake is also affected by the evil lava, and this brings a whole new set of trouble to Never Land.

Jake is trying to show Izzy he loves her but is doing this with pain and abuse because of the lava.

Izzy wants to help Jake, but she does not want anyone else to know what is going on.

This story is a bit more dramatic but still tries to keep to canon most of the time.

8. The Day of the FOOT

Peter Pan fanart

Out of nowhere, a man called Shawn appears in Never Land, and he vows revenge on Peter Pan.

Somehow he succeeds in taking over Never Land, and he is able to capture Peter and almost everyone else.

Jake is now the only one who can save his friends and the rest of Never Land.

But he isn’t sure if he can do this alone, so he allies with one of his enemies.

The majority of this story is told from Jake’s perspective, giving a good insight into his thoughts and actions during the story.

9. Legend of the Vampirates

Wendy fanart

It is Halloween and in Never Land they celebrate this in a big way.

Peter Pan invites Wendy and her brothers to come trick or treating in Never Land.

They also tell scary stories, and Wendy and her brothers learn of the story of the evil vampire pirates.

But then all of them discover that these vampirates aren’t just part of an old scary story but really exist.

Now they all have to survive Halloween and ensure they do not get bitten.

This story is a bit darker but still also very fun to read.

10. Pirate Twins

Pregnant Izzy

This story takes place in the future, where Jake and Izzy are both adults.

They are actually married to each other, and Izzy is pregnant with twins.

The story follows the two as they prepare for the children’s birth and what they are willing to do to create a safe world for them.

It is a sweet short story that shows what might happen when these pirates do grow up.

Jake and The Never Land Pirates Fanfiction: Conclusion

I hope this article has helped you find some great Jake and The Never Land Pirates fanfiction!

These 10 are just a small sample of all the amazing stories available.

So you may want to look at the other fanfics with this tag and find your own favorite among them.

And if you have questions about this topic, feel free to leave a message in the comments below!

Lastly, if you want to read more top fanfiction posts on this blog, then check out:

Legal Information

This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Recent Posts

Author Trivia

Which Harry Potter book is JK Rowling's favorite? Click the image above to see if your guess is right!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More Posts